The highly anticipated return of gaming’s iconic meat hero, Super Meat Boy, was met with a mixed reception. Super Meat Boy 3D was intended to redeem the series after the poor reception of Forever, and while it largely succeeded creatively, its player numbers suggest otherwise.
The game scored an average of 7.5/10 on Metacritic – a respectable result, yet it fell short of the genre-defining impact its predecessor made 15 years ago. On Steam, however, player reception was considerably warmer, with 87% positive reviews praising its successful adaptation of the original’s spirit into a 3D environment.
Despite favorable reviews, player interest remained low. At its peak, Super Meat Boy 3D registered only 621 concurrent players – a stark contrast to the original game’s audience. Intriguingly, the classic 2D version still attracts more players today than the new 3D installment. While its presence on Game Pass might mitigate the situation slightly, the franchise’s enduring appeal largely rests on the legacy of Edmund McMillen.
Despite the low online engagement, developer Sluggerfly achieved a notable creative success. Reviews are filled with enthusiasm, hailing the game as “the first good installment since 2010,” finally departing from the monotonous runner format. Players particularly commend the precise jumping mechanics and tight controls, which many liken to the original’s acclaimed feel.